Lol. I like how the one I spent an entire afternoon making from scratch --that matches the color scheme of the forum-- isn't even in the poll.
Between the two? Old one. The new one exchanges color for two little sparkle thingies...and I don't think that's a fair trade. Besides, it looks like all he did was a Desaturate on the gold portion and add the blue line and sparklies. Noob work imo. =)