alright, the best RPG ever I would easily say to be:
this is probably around almost as old as BW so you do not have it, so here is the link to download my favorite version:
I have a couple others too, but oh well. anyways, another classic one would be Alien vs. Predator, I am not sure how old this one is but it was made years ago. I have lots of versions of this, and after opening up a few this is what I found to be most resembling of my favorite one.
if you want the original of that, which is actually very different from that version and not as good in my opinion, ask. now, my second favorite RPG would be a game that I remember playing a long time ago but forgot the name for so I cannot post it up here. Final Fantasy III is still played, and that is also a good one. I also spent 6 months making MY rpg, Alien v Predator 2.
http://nd-prep.hypermart.net/Alien v Predator 2.scx
another important thing to remember in judging these (excluding mine, which is still a couple years old) is that they were all made with standard staredit and no other porgrams. I believe that there are so many good RPGs out there it is dumb to even try to make a poll, expecially one in which you only put up one classic and really good one (there were a few really good versions of elements when it first came out.) I mean games like Winterglades and Elements made up around half the broodwar UMS games being played at the times in which they were released. before i make this post an epic, as if I already hadn't..
anyone else have some good rpgs? lol
edit: took out some stuff that contradicted myself a bit, since winterglades is a BW map. and why is it whenever i hit delete button it ends my editing?