I voted for T3 only because I have waited for ten years for the thing so I better vote for it. PoTC was insanely better then I expected. I love pirates so I was just glad that someone made a pirate movie, and then on top of that it was actually really good. T3 had more action, but that is because it was built to be an action movie, the whole thing was one giant action sequence. PoTC had more plot. Nemo wasn't horrible, slightly anoying though. The funny thing is all of them kicked Reloaded's ass.